Garmin CIRQA Best Overall
Key details
- Display
- Screenless band
- Battery Life
- Up to 10 days
- GPS
- Connected GPS via phone
- Subscription
- None required
Garmin's argument with this band is that the things people usually pay a subscription for, such as recovery context, training readiness, and overnight data, can live on a device you own outright. We think the argument holds. The CIRQA logs more than 80 activities, notices walks and rides on its own, and tracks heart rate around the clock. There is no membership to lapse and no tier of insight held back, which is exactly what a reader searching this way is hoping to find.
The screenless body is the decision you have to make. There is no display at all, so the time, your step count, and your heart rate are things you read in the Garmin Connect app rather than on your wrist. What you get in return is a 17-gram band with a soft nylon strap that stays out of the way overnight, does not light up a dark bedroom, and runs about ten days between charges. If you check your stats constantly, this will frustrate you. If you prefer to see the week laid out later, it is a relief.
One button on the band starts an activity without digging out a phone, and the case is rated to 50 meters, so pool laps and showers are fine. We like how little there is to fiddle with: no menus to learn, no notifications competing for a glance, no reason to touch it mid-run. It is the least distracting tracker we handled in this group by a wide margin.
The comparison worth making is with the MorePro below, which gives you a bright screen, a week of battery, and 120 sport modes for a fraction of the outlay. The Garmin is for the buyer who wants a wide activity list and a device that disappears, and it delivers on both without asking for a credit card.
Pros
- 80+ activities, many detected automatically
- About 10 days of battery per charge
- 17 grams with a soft nylon band
- 50-meter water resistance
Cons
- GPS comes from your phone, not the band
For anyone who wants serious activity tracking without another monthly bill, this is our pick, as long as you do not need to read the time off your wrist.